Have a listen to this parent, reflecting on homework after helping her son:
(Direct link to the TikTok)
A decade ago I wrote that “I question the value of most homework“, and that still stands true. This parent adds an element that I hadn’t thought of.
Over the years I’ve restated my thoughts a number of times, but I’ll try to be succinct here.
When is homework a valuable use of a child’s time?
1. It usually isn’t. I want to start and end with this point because we have students in school for most of their waking hours. We don’t have a clue what they go home to and how much time and support they have, if any, with parents after parents get home from work. What we do know is that there is a lot of inequity in support and students who are most disenfranchised often have the least amount of resources to get homework done. The school day is long enough, and school is where there is the most equity for supporting student needs.
2. When they are doing extensions on work they want to do, or is hard to do at school.
Examples:
• An assignment that provides choices and those choices include doing extra or extending learning beyond the classroom… but done by choice, not required.
• A passion project where a student might work with a parent using a tool at home that isn’t available at school, like a scroll saw or soldering iron for example.
3. When they are asked to teach something to their parent, or interview them.
Examples:
• Teach you parent 3 different ways to add together two 3-digit numbers
• Find out where your grandparents were born, or interview your parents about your heritage.
*Both of these examples require sensitivity to provide alternatives for some students where these assignments might be challenging for them.
4. When ample time has been given in class, and students didn’t use their time well.
Note: Sometimes kids need more scaffolding at school to help prevent this from happening, but as long as they are capable of doing the work, this is a logical consequence.
5. Occasionally when big projects or presentations are due, homework might be necessary.
Note: This should be something only required occasionally, not weekly. Sometimes work piles up a bit around big deadlines. It’s healthier to teach students that some deadlines like presentations matter and need to get done on time, while other things can include extensions and more time at school for support.
6. Go back and read #1 again. That’s it!
Like this:
Like Loading...